Title: The Sorrows of Young Werther
Author: Goethe
Genre: Classics
Publisher: Modern Library
First published: 1774 (as Die Leiden des jungen Werther)
Pages: 176
Rating: 5 out of 10
I couldn't quite bring myself to enjoy this short tragedy by Goethe. It
wasn't even 200 pages, but it took me longer than I had been expecting
to get through it.
It is the story of a young man in 1700's
Germany named Werther. He falls in love with a young woman named Lotte,
but she is already engaged to another man. Even after she is married,
Werther continues to love her, and they form a friendship, which is both
heavenly and torturous to the despairing Werther.
The main
thing that I disliked here was that I just wanted Werther to grow up and
get over it. Reading the paragraph above, I must admit it is relatively
sad, but really now. It doesn't even sound like the plot of a tragedy,
just perhaps an unfortunate sub-plot.
Werther sees negativity in
everything, and is constantly wishing he was dead and dwelling on
suicide and weeping over his letters / journal. I have to admit that
sometimes, the idea of a tragic, heartbroken man braving the sorrows of
life can be an appealing story in some strange way. But rather than suffer in
silence, Werther does so loudly and wants everyone to know it. Rather
than gathering strength from his ordeals, he lets them weaken him into a
weepy fool. I couldn't like him or feel any sympathy for him.
This
book would have been agony if not for Goethe's skillful
brilliance. He is, of course, one of the greatest writers of all time,
and even in a book I can't particularly say I liked, he still manages to
write beautifully and evocatively. His prose is majestically awe
inspiring at times, though it does tend to ramble on a bit and sometimes
wander and become pointless. I noticed while looking for quotes to
collect here that I found plenty of gorgeous paragraphs, but couldn't
seem to spot a single sentence or short phrase that caught my eye. And
I'm not writing down a whole paragraph on my bookmark.
I wasn't
familiar with the story of Sorrows of Young Werther at all coming into
it, and as I tend to start imagining possible directions a book could
go as I'm reading it, it somehow became set in my mind that Werther
should become a poet.
Goethe's beautiful writing is here attributed
to his character, since the book is Werther narrating in the form of
letters he is writing. So the man's letters prove he can write, and I
can certainly imagine him turning his sorrows into great material. He
even loves poetry, and is a fan of Ossian (who is mentioned quite a few
times).
Just a thought... but of course, Werther does nothing with his trials except dwell upon them in the form of cacophonous sobbing.
I couldn't say I liked this book, or ever came to sympathize with Werther.
Showing posts with label 1700's Germany. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 1700's Germany. Show all posts
Friday, March 22, 2013
Sunday, March 17, 2013
Review: The Blue Flower by Penelope Fitzgerald
Title: The Blue Flower
Author: Penelope Fitzgerald
Genre: Historical Fiction
Publisher: Mariner Books
Published: 1997
Pages: 240
Rating: 3 out of 10
I got through The Blue Flower in merely half an hour, thankfully. Believe me, even a short 30 minutes seemed a long while stuck in this terrible book.
It is the story of Fritz von Hardenberg, who will later become known as the poet Novalis, as he falls in love with and becomes inspired by a young teenage girl named Sophie.
I think it is safe to say that I thoroughly disliked every page here. A very prominent feeling I had toward it was the following: "huh...???"
First, there was the theme of "romance," which was ridiculous and strange. Fritz, who is 20, falls in love with Sophie, age 12. I know that back then, 12 was a common age to become a wife, but it still seemed off to me. Sophie was depicted entirely as a little girl, often coming across to the reader as younger than her age, rather than older. Oh and, at least you can take comfort in the fact that it isn't until she is 13 that she actually marries Fritz. And then Erasmus (Fritz's brother) falls in love with Sophie as well, randomly and without explanation. What? How old is he, now?
Another "huh??" aspect to this book were all of the many long, tedious German names and words that crowded every page. Some were long enough to be sentences in and of themselves. I think that if you speak German, or are at least familiar with it, this book would be a lot more relateable. However, to me, it definitely added an extra sense of separation from the setting.
None of the characters here were likable or interesting. In the first few pages, I thought that perhaps Fritz's rambunctious little brother, Bernhard, would grow up to become an engaging character. In the first few chapters, he runs off to the docks, dramatically threatens to drown himself even though everyone knows he swims "like a fish," and then quotes some deep philosophy to Fritz. However, this is the only time any spark of life or imagination showed in any of the characters.
The rest is pure drudgery.
I couldn't understand why Fritz fell in love with Sophie. She is merely a child, so it couldn't be that she seduced him with her womanly charm, or girlish charm for that matter. Sophie remains aloof with Fritz, and relatively uninterested.
There are two or three chapters where we get to read Sophie's diary, which confirms our impression of her as a dull, boring girl. Her diary entries are 2 sentences at the longest, and have nothing to say. Erasmus tells Fritz that Sophie is stupid, her head "empty as a new jug." And it's quite true.
However, Fritz is obsessed with her. I would question that he truly loved her. There was no romance in these pages, but I did get the impression that Fritz had come to depend faithfully on Sophie, wanting to force himself to believe that she was something special. I was disturbed, however, when he says toward the end of the book "I love Sophie more because she is ill."
It comes from nowhere, and is treated casually, justified. Doesn't anyone else think that this sounds wrong?
This book is a maze of long, foreign German words, a not-quite-love-story that we do not care about, and boredom. Not recommended.
Author: Penelope Fitzgerald
Genre: Historical Fiction
Publisher: Mariner Books
Published: 1997
Pages: 240
Rating: 3 out of 10
I got through The Blue Flower in merely half an hour, thankfully. Believe me, even a short 30 minutes seemed a long while stuck in this terrible book.
It is the story of Fritz von Hardenberg, who will later become known as the poet Novalis, as he falls in love with and becomes inspired by a young teenage girl named Sophie.
I think it is safe to say that I thoroughly disliked every page here. A very prominent feeling I had toward it was the following: "huh...???"
First, there was the theme of "romance," which was ridiculous and strange. Fritz, who is 20, falls in love with Sophie, age 12. I know that back then, 12 was a common age to become a wife, but it still seemed off to me. Sophie was depicted entirely as a little girl, often coming across to the reader as younger than her age, rather than older. Oh and, at least you can take comfort in the fact that it isn't until she is 13 that she actually marries Fritz. And then Erasmus (Fritz's brother) falls in love with Sophie as well, randomly and without explanation. What? How old is he, now?
Another "huh??" aspect to this book were all of the many long, tedious German names and words that crowded every page. Some were long enough to be sentences in and of themselves. I think that if you speak German, or are at least familiar with it, this book would be a lot more relateable. However, to me, it definitely added an extra sense of separation from the setting.
None of the characters here were likable or interesting. In the first few pages, I thought that perhaps Fritz's rambunctious little brother, Bernhard, would grow up to become an engaging character. In the first few chapters, he runs off to the docks, dramatically threatens to drown himself even though everyone knows he swims "like a fish," and then quotes some deep philosophy to Fritz. However, this is the only time any spark of life or imagination showed in any of the characters.
The rest is pure drudgery.
I couldn't understand why Fritz fell in love with Sophie. She is merely a child, so it couldn't be that she seduced him with her womanly charm, or girlish charm for that matter. Sophie remains aloof with Fritz, and relatively uninterested.
There are two or three chapters where we get to read Sophie's diary, which confirms our impression of her as a dull, boring girl. Her diary entries are 2 sentences at the longest, and have nothing to say. Erasmus tells Fritz that Sophie is stupid, her head "empty as a new jug." And it's quite true.
However, Fritz is obsessed with her. I would question that he truly loved her. There was no romance in these pages, but I did get the impression that Fritz had come to depend faithfully on Sophie, wanting to force himself to believe that she was something special. I was disturbed, however, when he says toward the end of the book "I love Sophie more because she is ill."
It comes from nowhere, and is treated casually, justified. Doesn't anyone else think that this sounds wrong?
This book is a maze of long, foreign German words, a not-quite-love-story that we do not care about, and boredom. Not recommended.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

