Title: Original Sins
Author: Peg Kingman
Genre: Historical Fiction
Publisher: W.W. Norton & Company
Published: 2010
Pages: 448
Rating: 7 out of 10
Original Sins is the story of Grace Pollocke, a married woman in
1800's Pennsylvania who is unexpectedly reunited with a childhood friend
- Anibadh, who fled from a life of slavery in Virginia years ago. Why
would a runaway slave return and risk being discovered? When Grace asks
herself the same question, she finds that Ani has returned in search of
her daughter, still a slave at a plantation in Virginia, which just so
happens to be owned by Grace's long-lost cousins. Concealing her
identity, Grace travels with them to their home, in search of Anibadh's
daughter.
I really enjoyed reading this book. The feeling of it was very sophisticated and authentic, and Grace is a wonderful character.
Something
that struck me as different, perhaps even unique, was the view that the
main character so openly voices through-out the story. Unlike most
women in the 1800's, she does not believe in God, and could in fact be
called an atheist. Being born in Scotland and having also lived in
China, she has something to compare the Americas to, and she does not
exactly shed a favorable light on them. It was interesting how some of
the negative things Grace observed are still going on to this day. Maybe
the author was using the story to make a point.
I loved the main
character of Grace. She is a struggling painter, married to the man of
her dreams, and struck me at once as intelligent and personable. I loved
the way that she had "deep thoughts" about certain things, musing about
marriage, freedom, religion, and smaller things. She is a very
perceptive and insightful character.
However, while Grace's
character is well written, the author relies far too heavily on her to
carry the plot. The other characters - Dan, Anibadh, Diana, and Julia
Grant, among others, are not so well written. They are always in the
shadows, and we are never really sure about them. We know basics about
them, but beyond that, they are a mystery.
The author tended to
be very good at writing "bad" characters, such as the assuming,
arrogant, self righteous women whom Grace stays with, but not so
talented at portraying "good" characters. Julia Grant, an unexpected
ally of Grace's, is simply a nice girl, and seemed just a bit too
stereotypically good to me, as if the author was saying "She's on our
side - does anything else matter?"
However, the shallow women who are
certainly not on Grace's side are just so much fun to read about, it
almost makes up for it. The author captured their conversations,
meaningful sighs, and raised eyebrows perfectly. They may not have been
delved into very deeply, but they were certainly realistic.
Kingman
knows authentic speech from the 1800's, I was happy to find. Little
phrases such as "Well, I swan..." or "Dash it all!" were strewn
through-out the book. And she certainly did her research if she even
knows little, less easy to remember facts, such as that United States of
America was abbreviated a certain way back then, not just USA.
I
almost regret to list the worst thing about this book - I truly did
enjoy reading it, and I feel that I owe a more favorable review.
However,
unlike most good books I have read, this one started off marvelously,
and then once it got past the middle, went downhill.
This book is
complicated. It could have easily been stretched out into an extremely
long story, or even two books. Complexity and complications are
something that I usually love, but here, they seemed out of place. It
was simply unnecessary, and it slowed down the plot.
Do we really
need to read pages and pages about Julia's chemistry experiments? When
she sends Grace something to help whiten laundry, do we really need to
read for 2 pages, Julia's instructions on how to use it? Some of these
things do come in handy later, but the author could have just said that
Julia sent her some detergent.
I was disappointed by the downfall of the story. The beginning was just so good!
And yet, the story gets wrapped up in its own plot, and Kingman does not seem to know how to simplify, and where to do it.
By
the ending pages of the story, I just wanted to be done with it. The
trial at the end went on for I don't know how long... About 15 pages?
And it was not even one of those interesting trials. They were only
asking everyone normal questions.
It was things such as this that
really slow the story down. We simply don't need to read all of that.
Kingman takes the saying "show the reader, don't tell them" too far!
I
know that my review has listed a lot of negative points to this book,
but I hope that it does not discourage you too much from reading it.
Especially toward the beginning, this book was just wonderful to read,
truly what historical fiction should be. It was good enough to make up
for the slower ending chapters, and I am glad that I read it.
There is a prequel, which I will be looking for at my library.
Showing posts with label Slavery. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Slavery. Show all posts
Monday, March 18, 2013
Thursday, March 14, 2013
Review: Amos Fortune, Free Man by Elizabeth Yates
Title: Amos Fortune, Free Man
Author: Elizabeth Yates
Genre: YA / Historical Fiction
Publisher: Puffin
Published: 1950
Pages: 192
Rating - 4 out of 10
Amos is raised as the prince of an African tribe, until he is one day kidnapped by slave traders. In 18th Century Massachusetts, he lives in slavery for nearly the rest of his life, always remembering his proud heritage and the freedom that he once had. Finally, as an elderly man, he is able to regain his freedom.
This simply written story, based on true events, chronicles the life and hardships of one man before and after he is released from slavery. I thought that this book was a bit too abruptly written and factual, never revealing much of Amos Fortune's feelings or emotions, but it was still relatively well drawn.
Something that I strongly noticed about this book was its view of racism. The narrative voice of Amos also seems not to view slavery as an evil, but rather as the way of the world, which he was simply unfortunate enough to get caught up in. Despite of course yearning for his freedom, he also defends slavery and slave owners. At one point, Amos even expresses gratitude that he was kidnapped and brought to slavery, because his native tribe was (gasp) pagan and savage, and now he gets to learn about God and see technology that he would have never known about otherwise. When he requests his freedom from a slave-owning couple that he is particularly close to and addresses as his "friends," they instead sell him at an auction. Instead of recognize this as a betrayal, Amos gladly accepts this turn of events and hopes that the money his so called "friends" make on selling him will be helpful to them.
All in all, this is a book on slavery written in 1950 by a white woman, and her viewpoint shows this clearly. I can imagine white people reading this book to their children in 1950, while I cannot imagine African American women doing the same.
Well intended, but not entirely successful.
Author: Elizabeth Yates
Genre: YA / Historical Fiction
Publisher: Puffin
Published: 1950
Pages: 192
Rating - 4 out of 10
Amos is raised as the prince of an African tribe, until he is one day kidnapped by slave traders. In 18th Century Massachusetts, he lives in slavery for nearly the rest of his life, always remembering his proud heritage and the freedom that he once had. Finally, as an elderly man, he is able to regain his freedom.
This simply written story, based on true events, chronicles the life and hardships of one man before and after he is released from slavery. I thought that this book was a bit too abruptly written and factual, never revealing much of Amos Fortune's feelings or emotions, but it was still relatively well drawn.
Something that I strongly noticed about this book was its view of racism. The narrative voice of Amos also seems not to view slavery as an evil, but rather as the way of the world, which he was simply unfortunate enough to get caught up in. Despite of course yearning for his freedom, he also defends slavery and slave owners. At one point, Amos even expresses gratitude that he was kidnapped and brought to slavery, because his native tribe was (gasp) pagan and savage, and now he gets to learn about God and see technology that he would have never known about otherwise. When he requests his freedom from a slave-owning couple that he is particularly close to and addresses as his "friends," they instead sell him at an auction. Instead of recognize this as a betrayal, Amos gladly accepts this turn of events and hopes that the money his so called "friends" make on selling him will be helpful to them.
All in all, this is a book on slavery written in 1950 by a white woman, and her viewpoint shows this clearly. I can imagine white people reading this book to their children in 1950, while I cannot imagine African American women doing the same.
Well intended, but not entirely successful.
Friday, March 1, 2013
Review: 47 by Walter Mosley
Title: 47
Author: Walter Mosley
Genre: YA / Historical Fantasy / Science Fiction
Publisher: Little & Brown Books
Published: 2006
Pages: 240
Rating - 5 out of 10
On a cotton plantation in 1832 Georgia, 47 is a young slave forbidden from having an actual name. He has resigned himself to his miserable position in life as the way that things work. It is not until a mysterious boy named Tall John arrives at his home that he begins to question everything he has been taught to accept.
This book is certainly unique - I don't think that I have ever read another book that blends Historical Fiction with Sci-Fi. I thought that the historical elements of this book were more dominant, but there are definite, quite obvious science fiction leanings as well.
Tall John tells 47 that he is on a mission to defeat an evil race called the Calash, who are attempting to take over the galaxy, and tells him of his voyages across space and time, presumably being from the future. He says that he has come to this Georgia plantation because the Calash have disguised themselves as the cruel, white overseers and slave owners there.
Despite the bold, adventurous plot device, I didn't think that Mosley was able to completely pull it off. All the scenes where the two genres inter-mingle seem forced and out of place, and the scenes that are sci-fi altogether - when 47 meets people from another galaxy, for example - seem to clash with the rest of the book.
The most interesting thing about this book was trying to piece together what was actually happening. There are hints that Tall John is an escaped slave, not an intergalactic time traveler. Was he inventing these stories, in order to provoke 47 into questioning and rebelling against the world he lived in? Telling the boy stories of the evil Calash and translating them to the hated slave-owners could have been a tactic to get 47 to acknowledge how wrong they were. And, his name alone brings to mind "tall tale."
An interesting read.
Author: Walter Mosley
Genre: YA / Historical Fantasy / Science Fiction
Publisher: Little & Brown Books
Published: 2006
Pages: 240
Rating - 5 out of 10
On a cotton plantation in 1832 Georgia, 47 is a young slave forbidden from having an actual name. He has resigned himself to his miserable position in life as the way that things work. It is not until a mysterious boy named Tall John arrives at his home that he begins to question everything he has been taught to accept.
This book is certainly unique - I don't think that I have ever read another book that blends Historical Fiction with Sci-Fi. I thought that the historical elements of this book were more dominant, but there are definite, quite obvious science fiction leanings as well.
Tall John tells 47 that he is on a mission to defeat an evil race called the Calash, who are attempting to take over the galaxy, and tells him of his voyages across space and time, presumably being from the future. He says that he has come to this Georgia plantation because the Calash have disguised themselves as the cruel, white overseers and slave owners there.
Despite the bold, adventurous plot device, I didn't think that Mosley was able to completely pull it off. All the scenes where the two genres inter-mingle seem forced and out of place, and the scenes that are sci-fi altogether - when 47 meets people from another galaxy, for example - seem to clash with the rest of the book.
The most interesting thing about this book was trying to piece together what was actually happening. There are hints that Tall John is an escaped slave, not an intergalactic time traveler. Was he inventing these stories, in order to provoke 47 into questioning and rebelling against the world he lived in? Telling the boy stories of the evil Calash and translating them to the hated slave-owners could have been a tactic to get 47 to acknowledge how wrong they were. And, his name alone brings to mind "tall tale."
An interesting read.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


