Showing posts with label Napoleon Bonaparte. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Napoleon Bonaparte. Show all posts

Wednesday, March 27, 2013

Review: The Monsters of St. Helena by Brook Hansen

Title: The Monsters of St. Helena
Author: Brook Hansen
Genre: Historical Fiction
Publisher: Farrar Giroux & Straus
Published: 2002
Pages: 320

Rating: 3 out of 10

I love the story idea of one of the most powerful men in history, Napoleon Bonaparte, being exiled to a tiny island filled with typical small-town "country folk." I have read an account of Napoleon's time on St. Helena's as seen through the eyes of Betsy Balcombe, but not one told by Napoleon himself, as I had been led to believe this book would be.

Well actually, the narrator for this story is... no one. The main character is decidedly no one. The focus is on no one. It's just one of those 'nothing' books.

When I opened the book, there was a very long list of every single character that was to be featured in the story, small or large. At first I thought to myself that this would be useful if the book were non-fiction. But on further reflection, I realized it was pretty useless. Hansen can't exactly list every single person on the island, so he is forced to choose only individuals he will feature in his story. Which is a lot. The list went on and on for three entire pages. I was already growing wary of this book, and I hadn't even technically started it yet. I was beginning to think that this would just end up being a tedious relaying of facts.

I was a bit confused when I read the beginning words: "Sixty million years ago, the plates beneath what we now think of as the South Atlantic Ocean buckled slightly..."
So now we are in pre-historic times?
The first chapter goes on to tell about how the island of St. Helena was first formed as a volcano, and died out over millions of years, and so on. It read like a history book, and while I always appreciate getting background information on a setting, this seemed a bit over the top.
Funnily enough though, I liked this part of the book (including telling us a little about the island's first inhabitant, a marooned sailor), much more than the actual story. At least this part was interesting in a meticulously detailed, factual sort of way.
The rest of the book was anything but.

Once we actually begin the story that has to do with Napoleon, we are first introduced to Betsy Balcombe and her family, as they first hear the news that Napoleon has been ordered to come to their island. After that, the book meanders along, relating the friendship between Betsy and Napoleon, the attitude of the local islanders toward their new 'guests,' the removal of Napoleon from the Balcombe's home to Longwood, and other such necessary plot points.

Hansen related all these events without interest. I wouldn't have been surprised to read in a conclusive author's note or something "I hated writing this book, and anything to do with Napoleon or history bores me..." Because seriously, that is how the book is written, like a long paper a tired student was forced to write, when he would much rather have been doing something else.

I found it odd how Betsy is portrayed, as so very young. She was 14 when Napoleon came the island, which in her time would have been old enough to marry and begin running a household. However, I kept picturing her as around 7 or 8, because that is how she is written. Perhaps even younger, at times.
I also found this a bit creepy, because in the other book I read about Napoleon's exile, Betsy and Napoleon were portrayed as having a sensual sort of chemistry.
This book doesn't go that far, but in later years, when Betsy would go to Longwood to visit Napoleon, there were many speculations that Betsy and Napoleon were having an affair.
So Betsy being cut down to act half her age here seemed very strange to me.
Her sister is a few years older (I cannot remember the exact number, probably 16 or 17) and she acted very young, as well.

This book was pretty boring. There is absolutely no focus to it. What is it even about? Not, as I would have thought, Napoleon's exile. It just isn't central enough. Nothing is.
There are a great many pages devoted to the building of a chicken coop. We see it being planned, the wood being gathered, wires deliberated over, the selection of hens... Really. And no, nothing significant about the chicken coop ever comes up in the the story, besides the small fact that Napoleon eats some of the chickens and their eggs. Well, obviously! The book kept going back to the chicken coop over and over.

At a few points, the book switched its setting entirely (to hundreds of years before, in England) to follow the story of Fernando Lopez, the first inhabitant of St. Helena's Island. These were written in italic (random?) and in the style of a play (even more random!). Some of the scenes didn't even feature Fernando himself, just people gossiping about him.

I can't believe that any author could read over this book and actually believe it to be satisfactory. In my opinion, he should have stuck to the early story of the island's beginnings and the marooned man who first lived there, surviving off the land on a deserted island. It was far more interesting... or maybe that was just in comparison to how dull the rest of the book was.

Monday, March 25, 2013

Review: The Diamond by Julie Baumgold

Title: The Diamond
Author: Julie Baumgold
Genre: Historical Fiction
Publisher: Simon & Schuster
Published: 2010
Pages: 320

Rating: 4 out of 10

Spanning two centuries, this book tells the story of the famous Regent Diamond, and the many historical figures involved with it, including Napoleon Bonaparte, Marie Antoinette, and Louis XIV. The diamond is discovered by a miner in Africa, and falls into the hands of the Pitt family. After cutting the diamond into perfection, the Pitts have a hard time finding a buyer. The stone is so priceless, even kings are unable to afford it. When the stone is bought at last, it goes to France. Going from a court wonder to gathering dust in the treasury numerous times, the Regent survives the French Revolution (when it is stolen by commoners) and the Napoleonic Wars.

This book was written very factually, which an incredible amount of detail. You can tell that little of this book is fiction, and it very often reads like a history book. All of the history fascinated me, and I personally love books presented like this. However, if that is not your taste in reading, this probably is not the book for you.

In the beginning, this book was very interesting. The complex historical depth, with just the tiniest dash of fiction, was very well done. However, the other three quarters of the book grew dull, and there were only a few scenes here and there that interested me. The description of the French Revolution was very good, but it is bordered by pages and pages of yawns.
This isn't exactly a long book, but that doesn't stop it from feeling like it, and the author was often going nowhere. I know that with this type of story, it is not realistic to expect a conventional plot-line. However, this book also lacked vision.

I wanted very much for the Regent diamond to become a sort of character in the book, like the Ring in The Lord of the Rings. We are always, always aware of the ring's presence in that story. Here, nothing even close. Often, we would be shown events that had little or nothing to do with the diamond, except that such and such person had seen it once in their lives, or something so insignificant as that. I never actually cared enough about the diamond. It almost seemed that the author had used the diamond to just write an account of France's history, and wasn't actually concerned all that much with the jewel.
The Regent was at first portrayed as possibly cursed, which was what intrigued me the most when I read the inside cover. The slave who steals the diamond from the mines cuts his leg open and hides the diamond inside, only to be killed by a man who wants it for himself. At this point in the story, the author says that the diamond "already had blood on it." A curse is mentioned here and there, but this possible aspect of the story dwindles away after a few pages.

All in all, this book was a little below average.

Tuesday, March 12, 2013

Review: The Princess of Nowhere by Lorenzo Borghese

Title: The Princess of Nowhere
Author: Lorenzo Borghese
Genre: Historical Fiction
Publisher: Avon
Published: 2010
Pages: 336

Rating: 7 out of 10

This is the story of Pauline Bonaparte, the sister of Emperor Napoleon Bonaparte, and her cousin, Sophie. Pauline is a stunningly beautiful, wild young widow who would rather be seducing handsome courtiers than donning mourning clothes. In an effort to control her scandalous behavior, it is arranged that she should be re-married to a Borghese prince, Camillo. Pauline's young ward Sophie, who is fascinated by her older, glamorous cousin, watches the two fall in love, only to be torn apart by Pauline's many affairs and selfishness. As Sophie grows up, she sees that her cousin is not so perfect as she would like to think, but cannot help but remain enamored with her. We see Pauline and Sophie go through life together, through Napoleon's reign, to his downfall and the ruin of their families.

I was skeptical when I learned that the author of this book was a Borghese prince himself, an actual relative of the characters in this book. The image of a spoiled prince writing a bad book, and getting it published through money and influence, came to mind.
However, I needn't have worried. Born with royal blood or not, Lorenzo Borghese is an author I will certainly be reading more of.

The Princess of Nowhere is a powerful picture of so many things - of life during the time period, of the intricate inner-workings of the infamous Bonaparte family, and of a doomed marriage that contains an odd sort of love story in the background.

The writing style was realistic and grounded, and so very life-like. I felt that I could touch every ostentatious silk gown that Pauline wore, that I could picture her grand palaces choked in glittering wealth.

Every character was well drawn, with Pauline, of course, being most memorable. Only recently did I discover that Pauline even existed, while reading another book. This glimpse into her life was such a realistic one that now I feel as if I have read twenty of her stories (as I have with Anne Boleyn, for example).
Pauline is a remarkably selfish, shameless individual. When her young son passes away, she lashes out in anger toward anyone she can possibly blame, including Sophie (for being there at the moment of his death) and her husband (even though he was hundreds of miles away at the time and never even knew Dermide was sick until it was too late). She has a talent for twisting circumstances around into whatever she wants them to be, and her logic often hardly makes any sense, though she seems to take her convictions seriously.
Pauline is also a very sexual person, and she isn't afraid of letting everyone else know it. In her time period, her behavior would have been doubly shocking and scandalous. Her countless affairs are a regular feature in the gossip columns and cartoons, which everyone in the royal family finds embarrassing except for Pauline herself.
Since she thrives off of attention, Pauline often feigns illness. Her sicknesses are such a regular occurrence that she has made her royal doctor a rich man, and he is by now quite used to coming in and prescribing imaginary antidotes to her imaginary sicknesses. In one scene, Pauline poisons herself and Sophie with arsenic, so that she will truly get sick. Her husband has grown weary of her games, and will no longer believe that she is ill unless she is actually near death, so she sets up her own, truly brink-of-death game. I was shocked, and would like to know if there is any bit of truth in this part of the story. Why poison Sophie as well?
In another scene, Pauline seduces a young man, just because Sophie told her she had her first crush on him.
Pauline is selfish and, at times, evil. She is scheming and treacherous, and you would do best not to trust her.
And yet, you can't help but love her as well. Amidst her affairs, we see that she truly does love her husband Camillo. Her actions cause her to lose many of those that she loves, and she seems child-like in how she wants to take everything back now that it is too late. And her wild behavior, though never to anyone's benefit but hers, is without a doubt entertaining and lively reading. Pauline is charming in how spirited and unscrupulous she is.
She is the perfect embodiment of an anti-heroine: One that we love and hate all at once.

Sophie was set up to be the main character in the beginning, but ended up taking second place to Pauline. Largely since she is a child for a majority of the book, she is never as strong a character as her older cousin, but I loved her all the same. Her fierce devotion to Pauline, even after being so mistreated by her, was interesting and sad. By the end of the book, Sophie has grown into a strong young woman, and the reader cannot help but think that she is deeper and more "royal" than Pauline could ever have been.

Prince Camillo Borghese was also a very well done character. When he is engaged to be married to Pauline (but having doubts due to rumors), he is enamored by her beauty the first time he sees her. However, it is not until he accidentally sees her asleep, without makeup or fancy clothes, that he decides to marry her. He says that now she will always be beautiful to him, because he has seen her "when she thought that no one was looking."
I found this endearing and very sweet, but already, it sounded as if he was not exactly the type of man that Pauline would be suited for.
After they marry, Pauline finds that her husband is prudish in the bedroom, and that he does not take the news of her affairs well. Though he plays along with her games for a time, eventually he tires of this and ignores Pauline - the one thing she will never be able to take. Even her attempts at seducing him are unsuccessful, as what he really wants is not a whore but a wife.
While Sophie vows to stay with Pauline until the end, whatever the consequences, he eventually dismisses Pauline with no intention of ever seeing her again. I had to wonder who, in the end, made the right decision.

The setting was interesting as well, and we glimpse brief touches of politics, though the book focuses largely on the characters. Napoleon's wars are not mentioned very much in the book, save for the fact that Camillo goes off to war. While this may sound unrealistic, I actually believe that the author's choice to not involve the Napoleonic Wars was a fitting one.
Pauline, in her neglecting to ever mention her brother's, and the world's, news went with her character perfectly. The only news she cared to read was the gossip about herself.

As is necessary, of course, in a book about an infamously sleazy woman, The Princess of Nowhere contains quite a few sex scenes. I am normally very picky about sex in historical fiction. It often just doesn't feel... historical.
The scenes here were quite heavy on description, but I suppose that they were necessary to fill out Pauline's character as a very sexual woman. Just as the scenes were hovering on Harlequin, they moved on.

I loved the way that the story followed the character's lives over many years, giving you a sense of time passing. Every emotion behind the events here was well written and believable.

I absolutely loved this book! Recommended.

Sunday, March 10, 2013

Review: The Emperor's Body by Peter Brooks

Title: The Emperor's Body
Author: Peter Brooks
Genre: Historical Fiction
Publisher: W.W. Norton & Company
Published: 2011
Pages: 272

Rating: 2 out of 10

In 1840, it was arranged that an expedition be taken up to exhume Napoleon Bonaparte's body from his exiled home of St. Helena's Island, and bury him in Paris, twenty years after his death. This is the story that the book bases itself on, though loosely.

I had high hopes for this book, but it failed to live up to even the most modest of my expectations. The Emperor's Body would have been more aptly titled something like Idiots in Love, or Pointless Romance. This is really all that I got out of it.

Henry Beyle, better known as the famous French author Stendhal, takes up most of the book. He is involved with the mission to fetch Napoleon's body, so you would think that we would see him occupied with that for most of the story, right? Wrong. He spends the first third of the book reminiscing about his experiences with a lover he has in Sicily, the other third longing for a new girl named Amelia, and the other third playing the "She loves me, she loves me not" game. Though the author constantly reminded us of Beyle's age (around forty, as I remember), he acts like a silly teenage boy.
His lover, to use the word flatteringly, is the young, beautiful Amelia Curial. She is being pressured to marry by some, and urged to take a lover by others. Confused and inexperienced, she tells Beyle she wants to be with him, but does not exactly say whether she means as a husband or as a lover. We never really find out.
Amelia was sickening, and I disliked her strongly. She toys with the affections of two men at once, all the while utterly undecided about what to do, and leads both to believe that they hold some claim over her. Though it sounds malicious, she really is just a senseless girl.
At the end, after everything is decided, she says to herself that now she "knows enough about love." So she considers herself experienced now, does she? In trickery and stupidity, perhaps.
I know that this is sounding pretty harsh, but I literally could not have endured another ten pages of these awful characters.

The real piece of the story that fascinated me when I read the description was the idea of Napoleon impacting people's lives so strongly, even from the grave. I have been stumbling across quite a lot of books about the Bonapartes and the Napoleonic Wars lately (just by chance), so I thought that this one would be a perfect book to end the sequence.
While I was forced to listen to Beyle moaning about Amelia, saying he wants her but can't take her because of what a good man he is, and Amelia saying one day she loves Beyle more than anything and the next day unsure if she has feelings for him at all (aaahh!!), I looked in vain for Napoleon.
He was not the focus of the story at all, but rather an interesting back story that should have been made more prominent. The only part of this book that I actually enjoyed (for a few pages, that is) is when they opened the coffin and looked at the dead emperor. These were the sort of scenes and details I was hoping for in this book!

This was a huge disappointment. Please don't bother with it.