Title: The Thirty-Nine Steps
Author: John Buchan
Genre: Classics
First published: 1915
Rating: 5 out of 10
Richard Hannay is an engineer who has traveled the world, and now finds
himself living in London. He also finds himself bored with life with nothing to do. Conveniently, that very night, a mysterious little man named
Scudder appears at his doorstep, and tells him a tale of spies, running
from the German secret service, faked suicides, and codes. Hannay
agrees to help the man by hiding him in his apartment, but on returning
home the next day, he finds Scudder murdered and his home ransacked.
After investigating a bit, he finds a black book that belonged to his late house-guest, filled with an illegible code. Knowing this to be
what the killers were searching his home for, he assumes that they will
be after him next. He also assumes that the London police will find
evidence enough to convince everyone that it was he who murdered
Scudder. Believing himself to have no choice, he leaps aboard a train to
Scotland. He journeys about the countryside on foot, in disguises, on
bicycles, and in stolen expensive cars, all the while deciphering the
code in Scudder's black book and unraveling the mystery of what is going
on around him.
Knowing absolutely nothing of the genre, I was
curious to read this book, which even I know is famous for inspiring the
spy / thriller genre. Minus the hot girl on our heroe's arm, I certainly
could find a lot of similarities to other spy movies I've seen (I have
to limit my knowledge to movies, as I haven't read nearly enough books
to make comparisons).
This was a lot dryer than what I
expected, and there was never any tone of desperation or stress, like I
would expect from a man running from two formidable enemies. Even when
he is captured, Richard seems to look upon all of the events with a
collected, factual state of mind.
This book was very unrealistic - and I know that spy stories always are, but this was different.
Such
as, wouldn't it have been better for Richard to disappear in London
(where he already was) instead of head for the country? He is always
bemoaning the fact that there is nowhere to hide there, while in London,
this would certainly not have been the case.
Also, a suspiciously
high number of absolute strangers were willing to help, and sometimes
take risks for Richard. This was, of course, highly unlikely, but the
main character never seemed to see anything odd in it.
Little things
like this really took my mind away from the story, and annoyed me. There
is a difference between probable (boring) and believable (well
written).
At first, this book started off at a racing pace.
Within just a few pages, Scudder has appeared at Richard's door, with
tales of spies and intrigue, and a few pages later, he is murdered and
Richard goes on the run. I absolutely loved it. It was Victorian with a
dash of James Bond.
However, after this point, the book got
progressively more and more boring up until the very end. The middle is
all just about Richard traveling, and besides the stolen cars, most
often not in very glamorous or "thrilling" ways. At one point, he is
even riding a bicycle.
I actually wondered, after Richard had been
traveling for awhile, if the author was tricking us, and the spies
didn't exist at all. In fact, I found myself surprised when the
spies finally materialized later, and proved themselves to be, indeed,
real.
Scudder was the very best part of this book, and I
fervently wish that he had lived, and gone traveling with Richard. That
would have been interesting, as the man got to know his traveling
companion without revealing too much, keeping Richard and the reader in
constant suspense.
Though it did not lend itself to the "fleeing"
scenes (code here for peaceful bicycle rides in the charming
countryside), the British writing was a good combination in the more
exciting scenes. Again, the beginning was the best portion of this
little book, and though I loved the tone and overall feeling of the
writing style, I wouldn't call this a "great book."
Showing posts with label Spies. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Spies. Show all posts
Wednesday, May 15, 2013
Monday, March 18, 2013
Review: The Secret History of the Pink Carnation by Lauren Willig
Title: The Secret History of the Pink Carnation
Author: Lauren Willig
Genre: Historical Fiction
Publisher: NAL Trade
Published: 2005
Pages: 449
Rating: 3 out of 10
This book begins after the bloody French Revolution has recently ended. Amy Balcourte, whose parents were lost to the guillotine, dreams of joining the famous English spy The Purple Gentian (following in the tradition of the Scarlet Pimpernel). When she gets a chance to return to France and live with her brother Edouard, she jumps at the chance, and goes about secretly tracking down the Purple Gentian, who of course falls in love with her.
This unabashedly chick-lit book was certainly an entertaining read, if you are looking for some mindless fluff.
It had its funny moments, and although it most likely wasn't written this way by the author intentionally, many of the dramatic, swashbuckling scenes made me laugh at how ridiculous they were.
I wish that I could leave it at that - because The Secret History of the Pink Carnation, which has been on my lengthy To Read list for quite some time, was relatively enjoyable.
However, there is no overlooking the implausibility of the plot, the painful characters, and weak writing here.
First of all, the whole thing was not very believable. There were plenty of gaping holes in the plot that the author patches up shabbily, if at all.
For example, the Purple Gentian, who is supposedly the most elusive and dangerous spy in all of France, is an idiot. A girl travels to France dreaming of finding him (as hundreds of girls do, as he is a tabloids heartthrob), and she finds him in a mere few days. He acts like a child around his mother, and he forgets everything else the moment that he is in Amy's presence. There is more, but in short, The Purple Gentian is no dangerous man.
Also, why would Edouard even invite Amy to France if, after that, he never shows an interest in her?
How did Amy discover where the Purple Gentian would be that night - and catch him - when the entire French police force has been trying to do just that for years?
And why would Geoff encourage the Purple Gentian to reveal his identity to Amy? Neither of them even know her! Geoff has never met her, and the Gentian has known her for a few hours. Geoff's excuse is that "not all women are shallow." Which also scarcely makes any sense.
This thing of there being an unending string of spies, all of whom have names based on colors and flowers, also seemed quite forced to me.
I have not looked into the sequels yet, but apparently more spies with color/flower names emerge. How will they ever pull that off? Even three seemed like a stretch to me, in this book.
I found the characters of Richard's mother, Amy's governess, and Jane to be endearing.
However, our two main characters - Amy and Richard - were insufferable, especially Amy.
Much like Bella in Twilight, Amy is always tripping, stumbling, falling, and blundering. She is also constantly wandering, clueless, into danger, though the Purple Gentian always comes to save her, of course. What is this attraction authors suddenly have with writing heroines that can't walk across the room without tripping and experiencing near-death situations?
Amy comes across as a senseless, idiotic girl without a solid thought in her pretty little head.
I also disliked that certain chapters were set in modern times, focusing on Eloise (a student who is writing a paper on French spies). They were jarring, and really took me out of the story about 1700's France. I skimmed over them hurriedly, and really could care less about Eloise's boots getting muddy, or her drinking hot chocolate, or the hot guy she had a crush on. This wasn't her story, and if this guy isn't going to be built up as a character and is only going to feature in a few paragraphs, why is he there?
Yet another negative aspect to this book was the bodice-ripping, Harlequin leaning it had whenever it reached a romance scene. These scenes were not only written in a sickeningly flowery, over-the-top dramatic manner, but they were just plainly too much. Kisses are described in lurid detail, and the many make-out sessions between Amy and Richard go on and on for tens of pages. Amy describes having her first orgasm as Richard fingers, her while lying the back of a rowboat being rowed by a third guy. These scenes felt entirely modern, and I felt that I wasn't reading historical fiction anymore, but some horrid romance novel.
All in all, this book admittedly did have its fun moments, but there were simply too many flaws for it be anything extraordinary.
Author: Lauren Willig
Genre: Historical Fiction
Publisher: NAL Trade
Published: 2005
Pages: 449
Rating: 3 out of 10
This book begins after the bloody French Revolution has recently ended. Amy Balcourte, whose parents were lost to the guillotine, dreams of joining the famous English spy The Purple Gentian (following in the tradition of the Scarlet Pimpernel). When she gets a chance to return to France and live with her brother Edouard, she jumps at the chance, and goes about secretly tracking down the Purple Gentian, who of course falls in love with her.
This unabashedly chick-lit book was certainly an entertaining read, if you are looking for some mindless fluff.
It had its funny moments, and although it most likely wasn't written this way by the author intentionally, many of the dramatic, swashbuckling scenes made me laugh at how ridiculous they were.
I wish that I could leave it at that - because The Secret History of the Pink Carnation, which has been on my lengthy To Read list for quite some time, was relatively enjoyable.
However, there is no overlooking the implausibility of the plot, the painful characters, and weak writing here.
First of all, the whole thing was not very believable. There were plenty of gaping holes in the plot that the author patches up shabbily, if at all.
For example, the Purple Gentian, who is supposedly the most elusive and dangerous spy in all of France, is an idiot. A girl travels to France dreaming of finding him (as hundreds of girls do, as he is a tabloids heartthrob), and she finds him in a mere few days. He acts like a child around his mother, and he forgets everything else the moment that he is in Amy's presence. There is more, but in short, The Purple Gentian is no dangerous man.
Also, why would Edouard even invite Amy to France if, after that, he never shows an interest in her?
How did Amy discover where the Purple Gentian would be that night - and catch him - when the entire French police force has been trying to do just that for years?
And why would Geoff encourage the Purple Gentian to reveal his identity to Amy? Neither of them even know her! Geoff has never met her, and the Gentian has known her for a few hours. Geoff's excuse is that "not all women are shallow." Which also scarcely makes any sense.
This thing of there being an unending string of spies, all of whom have names based on colors and flowers, also seemed quite forced to me.
I have not looked into the sequels yet, but apparently more spies with color/flower names emerge. How will they ever pull that off? Even three seemed like a stretch to me, in this book.
I found the characters of Richard's mother, Amy's governess, and Jane to be endearing.
However, our two main characters - Amy and Richard - were insufferable, especially Amy.
Much like Bella in Twilight, Amy is always tripping, stumbling, falling, and blundering. She is also constantly wandering, clueless, into danger, though the Purple Gentian always comes to save her, of course. What is this attraction authors suddenly have with writing heroines that can't walk across the room without tripping and experiencing near-death situations?
Amy comes across as a senseless, idiotic girl without a solid thought in her pretty little head.
I also disliked that certain chapters were set in modern times, focusing on Eloise (a student who is writing a paper on French spies). They were jarring, and really took me out of the story about 1700's France. I skimmed over them hurriedly, and really could care less about Eloise's boots getting muddy, or her drinking hot chocolate, or the hot guy she had a crush on. This wasn't her story, and if this guy isn't going to be built up as a character and is only going to feature in a few paragraphs, why is he there?
Yet another negative aspect to this book was the bodice-ripping, Harlequin leaning it had whenever it reached a romance scene. These scenes were not only written in a sickeningly flowery, over-the-top dramatic manner, but they were just plainly too much. Kisses are described in lurid detail, and the many make-out sessions between Amy and Richard go on and on for tens of pages. Amy describes having her first orgasm as Richard fingers, her while lying the back of a rowboat being rowed by a third guy. These scenes felt entirely modern, and I felt that I wasn't reading historical fiction anymore, but some horrid romance novel.
All in all, this book admittedly did have its fun moments, but there were simply too many flaws for it be anything extraordinary.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

