Title: The Four Seaons
Author: Laurel Corona
Genre: Historical Fiction
Publisher: Voice
Published: 2008
Pages: 389
Rating: 8 out of 10
Browsing through reviews right after devouring this book, I was shocked to find how lukewarm they were.
The Four Seasons was an excellent book that I savored every eloquent sentence of.
It
is the story of two sisters in 1700's Venice, Italy, who are taken in
by a convent of nuns. One sister with a gift for music ends up being
trained by Vivaldi, while the other is married to a wealthy aristocrat.
By
the end of the story, I loved both sisters dearly. The characters here
are strong and grounded, and we see them grow up, go through both
hardships and triumphs, and grow old.
And finally - a book that
truly captures historical Venice! Corona truly transports us back in
time to my favorite city on earth.
This book really is just
gorgeous. Every chapter is seeped in sweeping, elegant, beautiful
wording that I would probably read just for how beautiful it was -
regardless of the quality of other elements like plot and characters.
Laurel Corona, who even has a pretty name to match her style, is also the very first author who has captured music in words.
With
her descriptions, I felt that I could close my eyes and feel, rather
than hear, the music. It was a feeling that I have never before come
across, but it added a lot to the story. I was surprised to read, in the
back, that the author knew little musically and was not a musician.
The relationships
in this book are well woven: the sisterly loyalty and fierce
devotion between Chiaretta and Maddalena, the drawn out and reluctant
love story between Maddalena and Vivaldi, and the sacrificial and
confused love story between Chiaretta and her husband.
The other main
characters of this book are not people, however. They are music and
Venice. They go beyond the story and become the soul and basis of the
entire book.
A gorgeous, well written story. Highly recommended.
Showing posts with label Musicians. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Musicians. Show all posts
Tuesday, March 12, 2013
Monday, March 4, 2013
Review: In Mozart's Shadow by Carolyn Meyer
Title: In Mozart's Shadow: His Sister's Story
Author: Carolyn Meyer
Genre: YA / Historical Fiction
Publisher: Harcourt & Brace
Published: 2008
Pages: 368
Rating - 5 out of 10
This tells the story of Wolfgang Mozart's elder sister, also a talented musician. She longs to share in the fame and opportunities that her brother receives, yet lives her entire life eclipsed by his shadow.
It was interesting to learn about Mozart's flawed, dysfunctional family and his neglected sister. The book follows Nannerl Mozart's life from her childhood to her later adult years.
The writing style stiff and impersonal at times, while at the same time almost force-feeding tragedy and sadness to the reader. After awhile, it became more than annoying. It seems that Carolyn Meyer's chief attempt in this book is to relate to the reader this fact: Nannerl Mozart did not lead a happy life. The very ending of this book reads - "Tears brimmed in my eyes. I let them fall."
No happy ending, then. In fact, there is no happy beginning, happy middle, or anything of the sort. It is rather depressing, yes, but that isn't the worst part of it. Even the saddest tragedies should have their high, joyous moments, or else the sorrow will seem numbed and meaningless. How sad would "Romeo and Juliet"'s readers have been if they never saw how perfectly happy the two main characters were together in the first place?
Carolyn Meyer shows us only the downside of her heroine's story. As far as her fictional portrayal is concerned, her heroine had no upside at all.
Author: Carolyn Meyer
Genre: YA / Historical Fiction
Publisher: Harcourt & Brace
Published: 2008
Pages: 368
Rating - 5 out of 10
This tells the story of Wolfgang Mozart's elder sister, also a talented musician. She longs to share in the fame and opportunities that her brother receives, yet lives her entire life eclipsed by his shadow.
It was interesting to learn about Mozart's flawed, dysfunctional family and his neglected sister. The book follows Nannerl Mozart's life from her childhood to her later adult years.
The writing style stiff and impersonal at times, while at the same time almost force-feeding tragedy and sadness to the reader. After awhile, it became more than annoying. It seems that Carolyn Meyer's chief attempt in this book is to relate to the reader this fact: Nannerl Mozart did not lead a happy life. The very ending of this book reads - "Tears brimmed in my eyes. I let them fall."
No happy ending, then. In fact, there is no happy beginning, happy middle, or anything of the sort. It is rather depressing, yes, but that isn't the worst part of it. Even the saddest tragedies should have their high, joyous moments, or else the sorrow will seem numbed and meaningless. How sad would "Romeo and Juliet"'s readers have been if they never saw how perfectly happy the two main characters were together in the first place?
Carolyn Meyer shows us only the downside of her heroine's story. As far as her fictional portrayal is concerned, her heroine had no upside at all.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

