Title: Behind the Ice Curtain
Author: Dina Gabel
Genre: Memoir
Publisher: Cis Communications
Published: 1992
Pages: 507
Rating: 5 out of 10
I neither liked nor disliked this book. I am always especially
interested in reading memoirs, because I feel that they are capable of
providing such interesting, realistic pictures of historical events.
While a terrible detail in historical fiction may be more strikingly
written, when you come across some shocking fact in a memoir, you know
it's authentic, and there is something more impacting about that.
Behind
the Ice Curtain is the story of Dina Shapiro, a Jewish girl who grows
up during World War II. Her father is taken away and never seen again in
the early days of the war, but her mother stays with her, and the two
rely on each other.
Dina was lucky enough that she never experienced the true horrors
of the Holocaust, though she did lose her father, her home, and her
belongings. She was never in a concentration camp, but
her story is still impacting, told in a sad narrative voice.
Often, I feel that Holocaust survivors have amazing stories
to tell, but cannot quite word them well enough to let us really see into their experiences. This one was the opposite.
Gabel is a fairly good writer, but her story was not interesting enough
to carry itself through without the help of many flashback memories to
keep it interesting.
There were a few vivid like pictures here -
Dina faking an epileptic seizure to save herself from imprisonment, her
memory of convincing her father to buy her a bicycle... There was a very
sad paragraph where Dina says she collected bars of soap. They were no
ordinary bars of soap, however. All stamped with a letter J, they were
made of the melted down body fat of Jews who were burnt alive. Dina buys
as many as she can find (26), and later buries them in a Jewish
graveyard.
I never quite know how to review these memoirs,
because it seems wrong somehow to pick apart and criticize the writing
skills of Holocaust survivors.
Showing posts with label Holocaust. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Holocaust. Show all posts
Sunday, March 17, 2013
Monday, March 11, 2013
Review: Last Waltz in Venna by George Clare
Title: Last Waltz in Vienna
Author: George Clare
Genre: Memoir
Publisher: MacMillan UK
Published: 1980
Pages: 288
Rating: 3 out of 10
Last Waltz in Vienna is a memoir by a Jewish man who was involved with the events leading up to and during World War II in Vienna, Austria.
As much as I wanted to enjoy it, the author's writing style often gave me the feeling that I was being left out. Once in awhile, there were certain moments of warmth that shone through the rest of the text. These were mainly childhood stories about family and everyday experiences that you would expect when growing up. It was here that the author seemed to write most realistically.
However, the other 95% of the book simply never did anything for me. The politics, as viewed by an actual, normal witness of the events, were no doubt as accurate, but strung together clumsily.
Author: George Clare
Genre: Memoir
Publisher: MacMillan UK
Published: 1980
Pages: 288
Rating: 3 out of 10
Last Waltz in Vienna is a memoir by a Jewish man who was involved with the events leading up to and during World War II in Vienna, Austria.
As much as I wanted to enjoy it, the author's writing style often gave me the feeling that I was being left out. Once in awhile, there were certain moments of warmth that shone through the rest of the text. These were mainly childhood stories about family and everyday experiences that you would expect when growing up. It was here that the author seemed to write most realistically.
However, the other 95% of the book simply never did anything for me. The politics, as viewed by an actual, normal witness of the events, were no doubt as accurate, but strung together clumsily.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

