Title: The Confession of Katherine Howard
Author: Suzannah Dunn
Genre: Historical Fiction
Publisher: Harper Collins
Published: 2011
Pages: 320
Rating: 3 out of 10
This brief story recounts portions of Katherine Howard's girlhood, as
well as her days as queen and her disastrous fate. It is told from the
viewpoint of Cat, a naive girl who grew up with Katherine and now serves
as her lady in waiting.
The book starts out ominously:
"I
was thinking... this is who we are: the perfect queen and her faithful
retinue. Now, I wish I could go back, patter over the lavish carpets to
tap us on the shoulders, whisper in our ears and get us out alive."
(page 4)
I found this to be a good example of Dunn's writing. Almost
well written, but not quite. The potential is there, but an amateur
quality remains. In actuality, the above sentence is relatively
flattering, being more eloquent than most others in the book, but it
still doesn't exactly fit. First of all, Cat never views Katherine as
"the perfect queen," and with good reason. And who in the world
"patters" over carpets?? I suppose next will be carpeted tap-dancing.
Worse
than people's shoes tapping on carpets is the modern style of Dunn's
writing. There is a whole lot of sex talk between the girls, and while I
don't doubt that girls of any time period are capable of being curious,
their wishful conversations sounded just a bit too unrealistic.
Something
that greatly annoyed me was that the main character Cat is so
drastically overlooked. She remained definitively faceless and without
personality for the entire story. Coming into the book, I didn't read
the back cover, and I had been assuming that Katherine Howard would be
the narrator. When it became clear that the story was being told by
someone else, I kept thinking that on the next page, this person would
introduce herself and reveal her identity. But she didn't until about
page 50!
Her name is never, ever mentioned until quite far in, and
we have to guess for ourselves that she is the queen's lady in waiting
or maid or something of that nature.
I got a strong impression that
the author expected readers to just know that our main character was
"Cat Tilney, ladies maid" from the description on the back cover. And
absolutely no book should rely on that, in my opinion.
In the
same way of forgetting to mention her own main character's name,
Suzannah Dunn fails to mention or feature a lot of other things, too.
Before
Cat and Katherine come to court, they appear to enjoy gossiping about
the latest royal news with their friends. As girls, they hear about the
queen being taken away and replaced by a new one, who is later beheaded.
Of
course, I know who they are talking about - Catherine of Aragon and
Anne Boleyn. Later, they converse about Anne of Cleves as well. But it
struck me as very strange that they would never once mention any names.
Anne Boleyn's name is not featured once in the entirety of the novel,
and neither are any other of Katherine's many predecessors.
Katherine's
affair with Thomas Culpepper is mentioned often, but we never actually
"see" him. He is mentioned, but never featured in any scenes, turning
him into just a name of some guy.
The words "London" and "England"
seem to be avoided. Absolutely no sense of setting is given whatsoever,
which is always a major negative point for me, especially with
historical fiction, and especially with historical fiction that deals
with royalty. Kings and queens are ingrained so deeply in their
countries and their cultures, a writer ought to find it impossible not to mention them.
I can't fathom why the author seemed to go
out of her way to avoid specific names and titles, but it certainly
didn't do any favors for the story.
Before this one, the only
other book that I had read that prominently focused on Katherine Howard
was Philippa Gregory's The Boleyn Inheritance. Though I know that
Gregory is not exactly known for her accuracy, I have to say that that
book is leagues better than this one.
I also felt that Gregory's
Katherine was much more believable and probable: a beautiful,
flirtatious, silly girl who is ignorant and not all that intelligent.
Here,
Dunn's Katherine is described as not being all that pretty or charming.
She seems a grim, flinty girl who is wise beyond her years, mysterious,
and ever so solemn - a stark opposite of Gregory's version.
But it
doesn't seem to fit the history - Henry VIII had just left the plain,
solemn Anne of Cleves looking for something more entertaining, and chose
Katherine. Why would he choose another ugly girl with a grey
personality? And why would a wise, cunningly intelligent girl make
herself so easy to trap by continuing an affair with the king's
favorite? Perhaps this could be excused if Katherine was written as
being desperately in love with Thomas, but she wasn't. Katherine struck
me as an un-feeling, passionless girl.
So, the entire persona of Katherine didn't ever seem right to me, always a bit off.
After
the culmination of events with Katherine being investigated, the book
ends rather suddenly. It would be easy for a reader not educated on the
events to miss the fact that Katherine was actually executed.
The historical note at the end focuses far more on the executions of Francis Dereham and Thomas Culpepper, for some reason.
Since I have now said so many negative things about the book, I am trying to think of a positive one.
I
suppose that I did like how I finished reflecting to myself how
unlikely a contestant Katherine was for the throne. Unlike her cousin
Anne Boleyn, she was never groomed and pushed to catch the court's eye,
and grew up as practically a commoner. As she talks about news, faraway
at court, she obviously doesn't see herself ever becoming one of those
people she hears about.
The book wasn't actually quite so
terrible as my review probably makes it sound. It was easy to read, and
moved at a quick enough pace (though it did get bogged down whenever
there was a flashback to girlhood days). It was definitely below
average, but I didn't hate it.
The Confession of Katherine
Howard was a book that I simply didn't have strong feelings for either
way - though if I did, they would be more likely to lean toward
negativity. Don't expect any of the characters to have strong
identities, or the events any gravity, either. Like the vapid main
character, this was a dry book vacant of personality.
Showing posts with label Henry VIII. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Henry VIII. Show all posts
Sunday, March 31, 2013
Monday, March 25, 2013
Review: The Pleasure Palace by Kate Emerson
Title: The Pleasure Palace
Author: Kate Emerson
Genre: Historical Fiction
Publisher: Pocket Books
Published: 2009
Pages: 400
Rating: 2 out of 10
From beginning to end, this was a fluffy book that made for painful reading.
It is the story of Jane Popyncourt, who flees 1500's France to England with her mother at a young age. There, she does her best to blend into the royal court of King Henry VIII.
I was bored by the hollow characters here, especially Jane herself. Her thoughts seemed so wooden and scripted.
The writing was abrupt and hurried through, certain things struck me as a bit too unrealistic, and there were a few plot points that were never really tied up.
The basis of the story, which has Jane's mother fleeing her country, is never fully explained.
For a few chapters, Jane spends a great deal of pages coming up with an involved, elaborate plan to get the king alone in order to speak with him privately. However, this never made much sense to me because Jane seems to have a good relationship with the king, and sees him as often as she wishes. Surely she could simply ask to speak to him privately, or lower her voice? But no. Instead, she hatches a scheme to pretend-seduce the king, culminating in his being in his bedroom with her and about to undress her (is that alone enough?). At this moment, Jane tells him that actually, there will be no sex. In fact, quite the opposite - she wants him to do a favor for her. Considering the fact that Henry VIII was known for being so lusty and prone to tantrums (not to mention being a man), I found it very suspicious that he accepts this bewildering changing of the tides with little more than a twinge of disappointment. And to make everything even worse, Jane's secret request isn't even secretive. It wouldn't have mattered if she had asked the King in public after all. The whole thing was ridiculous.
The above paragraph is simply one example of writing that often made no sense. A smaller thing would be that Jane recognizes her brother immediately after not seeing him since she was 9 (I cannot remember how old she was at the time, but most likely around 20), and doesn't even make that big of a deal of their reunion.
Jane is always being described as innocent and good and child-like, though she does take a lover, which would almost certainly have lost her these titles in her day and age. The King himself calls her "child" when she is in her 30's, and not as a pet name. Um...
I was annoyed at Jane constantly referring to her romantic interest, Guy, as if it was the first time the reader was hearing of him. Hundreds of pages after we first meet Guy, she is still saying "I saw his brother, Guy..." or "I say a young man named Guy Dunois walking by..." Alright, we know who he is now!
I cannot think of anything I enjoyed about this poorly written book.
Author: Kate Emerson
Genre: Historical Fiction
Publisher: Pocket Books
Published: 2009
Pages: 400
Rating: 2 out of 10
From beginning to end, this was a fluffy book that made for painful reading.
It is the story of Jane Popyncourt, who flees 1500's France to England with her mother at a young age. There, she does her best to blend into the royal court of King Henry VIII.
I was bored by the hollow characters here, especially Jane herself. Her thoughts seemed so wooden and scripted.
The writing was abrupt and hurried through, certain things struck me as a bit too unrealistic, and there were a few plot points that were never really tied up.
The basis of the story, which has Jane's mother fleeing her country, is never fully explained.
For a few chapters, Jane spends a great deal of pages coming up with an involved, elaborate plan to get the king alone in order to speak with him privately. However, this never made much sense to me because Jane seems to have a good relationship with the king, and sees him as often as she wishes. Surely she could simply ask to speak to him privately, or lower her voice? But no. Instead, she hatches a scheme to pretend-seduce the king, culminating in his being in his bedroom with her and about to undress her (is that alone enough?). At this moment, Jane tells him that actually, there will be no sex. In fact, quite the opposite - she wants him to do a favor for her. Considering the fact that Henry VIII was known for being so lusty and prone to tantrums (not to mention being a man), I found it very suspicious that he accepts this bewildering changing of the tides with little more than a twinge of disappointment. And to make everything even worse, Jane's secret request isn't even secretive. It wouldn't have mattered if she had asked the King in public after all. The whole thing was ridiculous.
The above paragraph is simply one example of writing that often made no sense. A smaller thing would be that Jane recognizes her brother immediately after not seeing him since she was 9 (I cannot remember how old she was at the time, but most likely around 20), and doesn't even make that big of a deal of their reunion.
Jane is always being described as innocent and good and child-like, though she does take a lover, which would almost certainly have lost her these titles in her day and age. The King himself calls her "child" when she is in her 30's, and not as a pet name. Um...
I was annoyed at Jane constantly referring to her romantic interest, Guy, as if it was the first time the reader was hearing of him. Hundreds of pages after we first meet Guy, she is still saying "I saw his brother, Guy..." or "I say a young man named Guy Dunois walking by..." Alright, we know who he is now!
I cannot think of anything I enjoyed about this poorly written book.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

